The Gamebook: Concept Poll

Hey, all! Sorry about the size of this post, but I've begun brainstorming ideas for the Choose-Your-Own-Adventure gamebook, and I would like your feedback on choosing one to write. I have seven ideas I'm considering (including one sent in by a reader—thanks, Ben!). I'd like your votes, but I'd also appreciate any comments; if there are multiple stories you strongly prefer, feel free to let me know!

The Rosy Mists: A rookie adventurer journeys to a strange town to help with a monster problem, but quickly finds himself in over his head. Who is the bat-winged woman who keeps appearing in his dreams? Why must the gates close every night when the pink fog rolls in? And why are all the monsters so... seductive? [Sort of a standard "adventurer falls to monster girls" narrative.]

Verdant Bliss: When a less experienced trainee is lured into the corrupted Southern Evergreen, a Toxin Ranger must journey into a hellish forest to save his friend. He will face lusty plants, corrupted fey, and even a few demons. The very forest itself chisels at his willpower and memories, and he will have to journey swiftly to avoid becoming yet another willing prisoner of the Verdant Cataclysm. [Likewise, a "hero tries to resist steady corruption and temptation" story.]

Lounging in Ecstasy: An adventurer awakens within the Cabin of Mist, an extradimensional haven of wickedness and temptation. He must evade witches, demons, vampires and other temptresses to find his way out of a surprisingly labyrinthine inn, aided by a secret-peddling imp who claims to be bound into his service. Who is she? And, more importantly—how did he get here? [Sort of a mystery, with more focus on stealth than full-on fighting. Lots of hypnotists and mind games, not quite so many monster girls.]

Sensual Sins: An inexperienced summoner ends up in Hell. In order to escape, he must reach the cell of the Mad Succubus, who alone can send him back home. His route will be complicated by sex-starved petitioners, a haven of endless sexual indulgence known as the Gardens of Gluttony, fellow inmates seeking escape, a "redeemed succubus", Hell's criminal underworld, and something called the Spiral Bridge. [Lots and lots of demons, different temptations, and Bad Ends.]

The Court's Pet: A knight with limited hypnotic powers must infiltrate the Fey Courts to win his childhood friend from the Faerie Queen, with the help of a catgirl who desperately wants to be a domme and a barely-controlled druidess. He must deal with sensual intrigue, dangerous bargains, erotic espionage, and a bunch of horny fey who all seem remarkably uncertain who the Queen actually is. The only way to get everyone back home safely is to master her, but will he lose his own will first to the machinations of the Courts? [Intrigue, trickery, degradation, and seduction. Unlike the others, this MC might have a decent chance to dominate some fey, but it's still tilted against him.]

Salt and Rum: A young sailor, contracted by a sly noblewoman, must captain a skeleton crew across a sea of monsters. On the voyage, he will encounter seductive sirens, naive mermaids, sultry hypnotist pirates, and more. But what does the noblewoman want? Why is the crew all-female? And why is the only thing to drink on the whole ship some exotic brand of rum he's never heard of? [Monster girls, mystery, and femdom pirates. Not too dark, but it can go either way.]

Wet Dreams, Soft Mind: A young librarian's dreams are invaded and corrupted by a strange fey, who hypnotizes him into a world of erotic oddities and temptations—a shifting landscape of catgirls that are only lucid when orgasming, sphinxes who cheat at riddles, and flowers who want to see the world. [This would be a more lighthearted story than the rest on this list—think Lewis Carroll.]