[Premium Access] Gravity Falls - 2x4 Sock Opera - Group Reaction

I think Suraj just shouldn't ask questions and throw theories out in the middle of the episode. He does in fact talk the most. He should save those questions for the discussion, and maybe people wouldn't be so butthurt about it.

Joseph Mchenry

We all made theories when this show was coming out, Suraj shouldn't get shit because he made one dumb theory. Remember the Bill has a brother theory?

Gezno

I think if I were to make a deal I would want Mindscape powers like Bill on the condition that I am free to use them as I please, not under contract to Bill, immune to manipulation on a possession, dreamscape, or physical standpoint from Bill, able to grant similar protection and "no harm clause" to loved ones of my past, present, and future yet to be with certainty. In exchange Bill can get one favor that does not violate the above conditions of my deal request.

Lavota Carter

BIll is still a demon, but Dipper didn't actually say the deal again to seal it. The handshake was just for the one puppet as Dipper only asked IF Bill could tell him the answer and stop the computer from imploding. Bill didn't specify his side of the bargain during the handshake. Dipper made a mistake of thinking Bill would be fair in giving them both positive outcomes. Bill did stop the computer from imploding by destroying it.

Lavota Carter

Be careful of wearing your heart on your sleeve. You say you are not going to say more about how the comments hurt your feelings and then fill the reaction and review with how you feel about it. Also being snarky about it.

Lavota Carter

Please keep up the guessing - the whole point of this show is figuring out the theories and it's really great to watch people do it for the first time!

autumn

Definitely one of my favorite episodes of the show

mellie

Great reaction guys. Bill is so awesome. And keep doing the guesses, it's fun to see the wild theories.

Asadullah Khan

I like your guesses Suraj.

Frankie H

Why would anyone shit on you guys for just talking about your theories??? That's what watching a new show is all about...Anyway, nice reaction and discussion!

Cristal C

1) speaking only for myself Suraj, the issue is not trying to guess the answers to the mysteries but rather the WILD guesses. In Bill's first appearance he gets summoned by a ritual and Gideon even refers to him as a "demon". Now whether Gideon was being literal or metaphorical, the word "demon" is a good place to start asking questions about Bill and what he is. Instead you somehow jumped all the way to "HE'S THE UNIVERSE!" which is annoying NOT because you are trying to figure out the mystery but because it seems like you are ignoring the actual clues in the show. 2) Suraj also made a good observation here about how Bill turns the scene black-and-white when he makes an entrance, but notice that Dipper was asleep when that happened. That actually happened when Gideon first summoned him as well; the scene went black-and-white as Bill appeared and when he made his exit, Gideon, Soos and Mabel all jolted awake. And also the inside of Grunkle Stan's mind was also black-and-white, but Bill entered his mind while he was taking a nap. That should give some ideas as to how Bill operates. 3) As for Bill's apparent deal-breaking behavior. Notice what Dipper says before the handshake. Dipper: "Just one puppet?...Fine!" (he shakes hands with Bill) He never actually secured a promise from Bill that he would get useful information. Essentially he just handed over his body with no restrictions for free! Lesson to be learned kids. When making deals with mysterious supernatural beings, always be clear what the terms of the contract are!

Rexxon

Lol it's ok Suraj guess yo lil hart out

Justin Neason

I loved watching you guys react to this episode! It's one of my favorites. As for Bill following the deal, Dipper never actually made a demand. Bill implied that he would give Dipper the password but never actually said it.

Suraj don't let the youtube comments get to you. People on the internet are mean. Not worth your head space and emotions.

Thanatos

I love this episode and I am really excited for next weeks episode as too!

Commander Dodge

Atleast this shows that AOS fans are not that critical of opinions Normies have on the show as they watch the episode

Dredrakon

IKR? People need to give her a break.

Ah, the episode people point to when they want to back up their supposed hatred for Mabel's character.

Osvaldo Castanon

This was also uploaded on my birthday and this is my favorite episode to thank you and God bless you all

Jarryd Thompson

Awesome Episode

Dredrakon